Last year at Christmas veggie daughter decided to take a day off from vegetarianism and eat the turkey and all the trimmings with the rest of us. This year she is much more resolute, and turkey is definitely off limits, even if it is a pampered free range bird that spent its life listening to classical music and wandering outside every so often for a stroll in the sunshine. A Quorn fillet just wouldn't cut it, so I searched for a showstopping recipe to prevent her feeling left out on the big day. Various recipes were put to the diner for approval, culminating with her approving a BBC Good Food recipe for a layered barley, butternut and spinach pie with a hot water pastry crust. http://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/8639/layered-squash-barley-and-spinach-pie
With its triple layers of spinach and ricotta, barley and chestnut risotto and butternut and sage, it sounded suitably Christmassy and looked like a fitting centrepiece for a celebratory meal. I diligently read the recipe through, along with all the comments from others who had previously baked the pastry delight and discovered potential pitfalls, the main ones appearing to be that the recipe makes way too much filling for the size of pie, and that it needed a bit of spicing up. Some commentators didn't like the lemon zest, so I reduced the amount to a few strands rather than a whole lemon.
Here is the recipe from BBC Good Food, with my changes (surprisingly few, as I normally change a lot more in any recipe I find).
Ingredients
For the filling
- 1 small butternut squash (about 1kg/2lb 4oz), peeled and cubed
- a glug or two of olive oil
- 1 tsp sesame oil
- 1" cube fresh ginger, grated
- 1 tsp kochujang (Korean hot chili paste - along with the sesame oil this was a nod to our time spent in Korea)
- 3 onions, finely chopped
- 3 garlic cloves, crushed
- 100g mushrooms, sliced
- 85g whole cooked chestnuts, quartered (I used Merchant Gourmet vacuum packed)
- 100g pearl barley
- 1.2l vegetable stock
- glug of red wine that was left over on the side
- 1 tbsp dark soy sauce
- zest 1/4 lemon
- 250g/9oz tub ricotta
- 200g full-fat soft cheese
- 6 sage leaves picked and chopped
- 400g spinach (I used frozen)
- 700g plain flour
- 140g butter
- 85g/3oz white vegetable shortening (we used Trex)
- 100ml milk
- 1 egg, lightly beaten
For the pastry
![]() |
Little basket of garlic purchased at Lidl's simply because it looked cute. Each bulb is a single clove, I'd never seen that before. |
- Heat oven to 200C/fan 180C/gas 6 and roast the butternut squash with 1 tbsp olive oil, the ginger, sesame oil, kochujang and a clove of garlic for 25-30 mins until tender, then set aside.
- Meanwhile, heat another glug of olive oil in a large pan and cook the onions and garlic for 10 mins until soft. Remove two-thirds, then add the mushrooms, chestnuts and pearl barley to the pan. Sizzle for a few mins, pour in the red wine and stock, then bring to the boil. Bubble for 30 mins, stirring frequently, until the barley is tender and sticky and there is no liquid left. Stir in the soy sauce, season and set aside.
- I don't think I have mentioned cheffy son yet. He is one of veggie daughter's two older brothers and is a keen cook and in fact can genuinely lay claim to the title of chef, being a part time grill chef at a station eatery in London. During an expedition to the Thai food shop some fresh green peppercorns caught his eye. (We are lucky enough to have a Thai food wholesaler a mile up the road and a trip round their store is a treat. They also deliver online elsewhere in the UKhttp://thaifooddirect.co.uk/) The day we went, they had had an air freight delivery from Thailand and the array of fresh produce was impressive. We bought the peppercorns and cheffy son could not resist adding a few to the barley mixture.
![]() |
Cheffy son adding fresh green peppercorns |
3. While the barley layer is cooking, make the other layers. Stir the zest, ricotta, soft cheese and some seasoning into the reserved onions until smooth. BBC recipe called for parsley, which I had planned on taking from my parents' garden but forgot. I probably should have added basil instead.Take a third of the mixture and gently fold with the sage and roasted squash. For the final layer, boil the kettle, then tip half the spinach into a large colander. Pour over the boiling water to wilt, then repeat with the rest of the spinach. Tip the spinach into a colander and squeeze out all the moisture you can. Roughly chop, then mix into the remaining ricotta mixture. I foolishly only added half the spinach - if I make it again I would add the whole lot.
4.

Spoon in the spinach layer, smooth the surface, then repeat with the barley and finally the squash layer. Dome the squash mix slightly to give a rounded top. Roll out the remaining pastry to fit, brush the edges with some egg, then press the lid over the top. Trim the excess and crimp or pinch to seal, then decorate with pastry trimmings cut into leaves Can be covered and chilled overnight. The pie was massive - the recipe says serves 4 to 6, but they must have extremely hearty appetites. It would probably serve nearer ten, and we are definitely big eaters.

![]() |
Behold the beautiful layered effect inside the pie! |